Proposal Defence Scorecard
Score your research proposal the way a panel scores it — on the seven criteria, at the weights they actually carry. It takes about four minutes and it will tell you which section is costing you the most marks.
That is what you get if the panel rates you “Satisfactory” on all seven criteria — and it is a fail. The pass mark is 65. To clear it you need to average better than 3.25 out of 5 across the board. Most candidates who are quietly confident are sitting right around 60.
The criteria and weights below are taken from the panel evaluation form published by Universiti Malaya’s Institute for Advanced Studies. Not every university publishes its form — Taylor’s, Sunway and most private institutions do not — but the criteria are close to universal, because they follow what a proposal has to prove. Use this as a diagnosis of your proposal, not as a prediction of your mark.
Rate each criterion honestly
Read the two anchors before you choose. The common mistake is rating yourself on effort rather than on what is actually on the page.
Where you are losing the most marks
What the scores mean
Marks convert straight from the scale: a criterion scored 4 out of 5 earns four-fifths of its weight. The grade bands are the published ones.
90+ A+ · 80–89.99 A · 75–79.99 A− · 70–74.99 B+ · 65–69.99 B · below 65 fail and repeat the proposal defence seminar.
Three things worth knowing before your date.
Half the mark — a full 50 — sits in your Introduction and Literature Review. Candidates spend their last fortnight rehearsing the talk, which is worth 10. Rehearsing is not wasted, but it cannot rescue a thin problem statement.
Originality is recorded separately. Your Turnitin similarity index goes on the form under its own heading and is checked against the faculty guideline, but it earns you no marks. It can only cost you.
Attempts are finite. At MMU, for example, the defence is graded Satisfactory or Unsatisfactory, you get three attempts, and candidature is terminated on a third failure or on passing beyond the maximum period — which for a part-time PhD is fifteen months from registration. Check your own institute’s rule before you assume you have room to fail once.
Send us your two weakest sections
If this put you under 65, you already know which parts are doing the damage. Send those two sections and your proposal — we will read them against these criteria and tell you what the panel will ask. The first 15 minutes are free, no obligation.
Talk to us on WhatsApp